Concrete vs Dirt stall floors - Page 5
 
 

       The Horse Forum > Barns, Boarding, and Farms > Barn Maintenance

Concrete vs Dirt stall floors

This is a discussion on Concrete vs Dirt stall floors within the Barn Maintenance forums, part of the Barns, Boarding, and Farms category
  • Dirt vs mats for stalls
  • Stalling horses on concrete

Like Tree30Likes

 
LinkBack Thread Tools
    07-06-2012, 02:38 PM
  #41
Showing
I've only ever had dirt stalls with thick mats and plenty of shavings. I'd prefer concrete, but my mom is adamant against it (my parents tore all the concrete out when they moved in). My horses all lay down to sleep at night, and my older gelding lays down in his stall during the day as well.
     
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
    07-06-2012, 02:40 PM
  #42
Weanling
It's a playful forbidding. It's more like telling a friend, I forbid you to wear those ugly ass pants when we go out tonight!

Except in my case my farrier is an expert in natural hoof care. I pay her her expertise, and yes I do make my own decisions, I also weigh heavily on the advice of those I employ. I don't hire fools, I only hire the best I can find, so when they forbid me even playful joke, I am going to of course consider their advice.

Quote:
Originally Posted by MBFoley    
"Forbids" you? Really? Who is making the decisions about YOUR horse? Giving you advice, backing it up with evidence and you deciding to follow said advice is one thing but "forbidding" you to make your own decisions is not a healthy customer/client relationship.
Posted via Mobile Device
MBFoley likes this.
     
    07-06-2012, 02:48 PM
  #43
Foal
Quote:
Originally Posted by BigGirlsRideWarmbloods    
It's a playful forbidding. It's more like telling a friend, I forbid you to wear those ugly ass pants when we go out tonight!

Except in my case my farrier is an expert in natural hoof care. I pay her her expertise, and yes I do make my own decisions, I also weigh heavily on the advice of those I employ. I don't hire fools, I only hire the best I can find, so when they forbid me even playful joke, I am going to of course consider their advice.


Posted via Mobile Device
Ok, sorry, it's just one of my huge pet peeves when people give professional experts a sense of control. "My dr won't let me" "My farrier forbids me" "My trainer makes me" etc. It is fine for the way you are speaking, those who know that they really do have a choice in the matter but for some people they take it too literally and far too many people do not accept responsibility in the decision making process for their animals, their children or themselves, instead they pawn off that responsibility on the experts they pay for their OPINION, they are just that, human beings with an educated opinion, they are not gods or rulers.
Golden Horse likes this.
     
    07-07-2012, 04:50 PM
  #44
Foal
I see some UK people preferring concrete. I'm originally from Europe too and must say that what sold me on the house I bought here in the US was that the barn had a concrete floor! I looked at a couple of places that had dirt floors in the barn and I just wasn't feeling it...

I bed with straw too. It composts a lot quicker than sawdust, which makes a huge difference for me (I have limited acreage to spread it on and am too impatient to wait more than 6 months for a manure pile to compost). If you bed deeply enough with straw, it's (in my experience) no worse than sawdust/shavings. One catch with it is though that it has to be a little damp before it will absorb moisture. So if you bed with straw, make sure you lay a thick bed so urine can soak into the lower part of it. The top will then stay dry longer.
Golden Horse likes this.
     
    07-12-2012, 03:13 PM
  #45
Weanling
I am from OK and have bed on both concrete and dirt/clay floors. I see the benefits of both. The problem with the dirt/ clay is the horses are able to create craters in their stalls, whether that is from peeing or from digging. Even with rubber mats, you still end up with squishing of pee under them if you have a heavy peeing horse, esp since clay isn't the most draining. If I ever have to bring in more clay to fill in stall craters again it will be too soon.

Currently the barn we are using has concrete floors with drains (though the drains I am sure need cleaned out after many yrs of use) along with rubber mats on top. We bed on paper shavings and will bed anywhere from 5 inches thick down to just enough to soak the pee. Stalls are much easier to clean, and we have not had any soundness issues.
     
    07-16-2012, 01:50 PM
  #46
Yearling
We have 2-3 feet of sand and then a 1/2 foot layer of stone dust on top of that for comfort. In the concrete stall is where we keep the pigs.
     
    07-16-2012, 02:16 PM
  #47
Yearling
I have seen both dirt and concrete around here. I've never actually seen someone not use rubber mats so I don't know how much of a difference that makes.

I think that if I built a barn I'd probably use concrete. The dirt floors tended to stink more and be harder to take care of.

Quote:
No offense - but I guess it boils down to how much upkeep one is willing to do.

It's not healthy for a horse to spend extended periods of time standing on concrete - much less laying on it. No matter how deep the bedding, a horse can get down to bare nothing and mark up a leg while they are laying down. Concrete has tiny pores which retain odor.

We do everything as needed - add fill, shift mats, use lime, add shavings, etc. It's not hard - it's for the horses.
Okay, there's no need to imply that those who use concrete floors care about their horses less or are not as willing to work hard for them. At all. That was rude.

Also, I've never seen more or less soundness issues with either floor. And this is with both deep and shallow bedding systems.

Depending on how hard dirt is packed, I imagine it can be almost or as hard as concrete.
Ray MacDonald and MBFoley like this.
     
    07-16-2012, 04:35 PM
  #48
Green Broke
Interesting debate

I'm not sure what is under the rubber mats at my barn, but now I'm going to ask and find out!
     
    07-25-2012, 07:33 PM
  #49
Foal
I'd rather have concrete. We have dirt floors at the barn. We clean our stalls good but with concrete there would be less dips in the floor, easier to clean with a power washer when we have to do a big cleaning ob and the smell of ammonia would be a lot less.
Cinder likes this.
     

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Asphalt or pervious concrete as a stall flooring under a rubber mat? wguisbert54 Barn Maintenance 8 03-04-2012 09:32 PM
Wood floors in stalls KatieQ Barn Maintenance 34 01-08-2012 04:53 PM
Floors, dirt or cement? nkieffer61 Horse Health 24 08-14-2011 01:41 PM
Stall floors and storing wood shavings Salila Barn Maintenance 7 03-10-2011 03:29 AM
Wood floors in stalls Trailmaker Horse Health 11 02-13-2008 11:34 AM



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:56 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0