#2 I do not like the alligator seat, as I have an ostrich seat and I actually wish it wasn't so slippery. So I prefer the suede even though I have a slick seat barrel saddle. Aside from that, it seems well put together.
#3 This is my second choice. I like the construction of the saddle. It looks fairly well put together. I'd prefer a laced rawhide cantle, but that's a personal preference. And I like the tooling and silver details.
#4 To me, this saddle looks a little poorly constructed and I do not like the shorter height of the horn. I do like the height of the cantle.
#5 Again, the construction looks to have a little less quality. I kind of like the angle of the horn, and the height of it. But I also wish there was more silver details.
Hope that helps!