The Horse Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trail Bags- Cantle or Pommel?

8K views 20 replies 18 participants last post by  ArabLoverCDL 
#1 ·
I'm looking to purchase a bag for rides, and am not sure if I should get a cantle or pommel bag. Does anyone have a preference? I have tried both and don't really have a preference for reaching forward or back. Is there a difference for the horse?

Let me know what you prefer for your pony. Thanks!
 
#3 ·
A pommel bag is easier to access but a cantle bag can hold more or larger items. I have a pommel bag that I always use. My wife has a cantle bag but it is hard to get into while moving. Trying to unzip and rezip when done especially one handed.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
#5 ·
I dont use pommel bags, I tend to need an unclutered area to hang on, on occasion. i have a rear snug pack that combines a cantle bag with two drink holders, on the side I have a sponge bag on the on side. Off side is a easy boot bag, I put elytes and what not in the rear off side easy boot bag, If I am opening my cantle bag something has gone wrong. I pretty much just carry emergency supplies and snivel gear in it.
 
#6 ·
I have a personally preference toward cantle bags. More room for stuff; less clutter I have to look it. It just looks sleeker. My cantle bag has room for two water bottles (I believe I have the same model of Joe!), so that's very convenient. My horse doesn't even notice it's there.
 
#12 ·
Doesn't the beer get shook up? We have insulated saddle bags to carry beverages. They keep them cold. Also we use foam freezer packs. Not to promote a beverage but Mike's lemonade can be frozen and will stay cold on long trips on hot days.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeynaProof
#14 ·
I use both. Stuff I need to access while riding goes in the pommel bag (drinks, snacks, chapstick). Emergency kit stuff, spare hoof boots, lunch/horse snacks, goes in the cantle bag.

I like heavy stuff (water bottles) up front so the horse doesn't have anything heavy behind the saddle in the weak area near the loin. Also it is easier for me to get water bottles out of the front bags, I can't get into the back bags while trotting. However, the pommel bags sometimes get the excess loop of rein stuck on the bottom edge if I'm having a tight reins kind of ride and have a lot of excess loop hanging ;) That isn't as bad with the snugpax as with other brands I've tried.
 
#17 ·
I just took my new snugpax pommel bag for a spin and I really like it. It's a simple one with two bottle holders and a small pouch above the withers. It did not get in my way at all. I do have a larger cantle bag for when I go on longer rides so I can pack first aid and other supplies.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
#18 ·
I like pommel bags better because they are easy to access. But cantle ones are good for items you won't need right away on the trail - they can hold more and they are still accessible if you need to.
 
#19 ·
Excellent arguments on all sides. Thank you everyone.

I did an endurance ride with my girl this weekend (our first together!) and borrowed a pommel bag. Quite frankly I don't know that it's any easier to grab a bottle while trotting that's in the front than one that's in the back. We only get stuff out of our bags when we are walking. I'm not that skilled of a rider to fuss with things during a trot. I'm more focused on the trail in front and my girl's body language. I envy your abilities to multitask! I'll get there. Afterall, I've only been riding 2 1/2 months.

Anyway, I'm going with the cantle bag. My water bottle in the pommel bag kept hitting my knee when we were trotting uphill and ended up bruising me. The saddle I'm in is too short for me so I was a little crammed. Plus, it got in the way when I needed some mane to prevent me from going A over teakettle when she saw a stump monster. :) Good timing on her part.
 
#21 ·
I use both too. I think Stowaway makes the best bags! They don't bounce and there's a ton of space. I love the easy access to water bottles in my cantle bag. I use those zippered pockets for my emergency stuff like vetwrap, gauze pads, bute, clean washcloth, Betadine swabs, wet wipes, etc. I put my stuff I use on every ride in my pommel bag because it's easier to reach like granola bars/snacks, extra water, collapsible dog bowl, gps, compass, tissues, chapstick. It's amazing how much you can fit!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
You have insufficient privileges to reply here.
Top