I am completely in love with my stubben! They both look lovely, I wouldn't be shocked on the price of the stubben, it looks older but those saddles last FOREVER!
Definitely try both of them on, I tried 18 on Flynn before finding a good fit.
I can't see the pictures, but I have a Stubben and love it. Mine is 50+ years old, and is still in perfect condition, even though I found it in someones barn covered in mildew and ignored for about ten years. They are made out of fantastic leather, with good quality work, and last forever. I highly recommend them.