I would totally go with Lucy!!
She is only 8.. vs 15. Even though the old grandpa has the show miles, the young one still has lots of life in her! Since you'll have more money if you buy her, you'll be able to show her and give her lots of miles, too. Plus if you've been riding for 10 years, you would be more challenged with the young 'en. You'll have fun with her. I mean, not trying to say older horses aren't great, but you'd be better off with Lucy. :)
ps. You should post pictures.
Last edited by MoodIndigo; 10-31-2010 at 11:16 PM.