I know this isn't what you want to hear, but there is a very slim chance you are going to find one saddle that properly fits all 3 of your horses. :( especially since your horses seem to fit wide, regular and narrow trees! The only possible way you are going to find a saddle that fits each of them adaquetly is to get one with a changable tree..and then your looking at spending 2-3k.
The new pictures you posted are better, but you really need ones with just the saddle on the horse so there is no other objects obstructing our view. But I'll do my best and judge these as is. :)
Out of the 3, I really don't like the fit on either one unfortunately. :(
The saddle fits the morgan good in regards to wither clearance, however now we're getting into the area of the saddle being too narrow! You can tell from the picture of the back of the saddle that it looks like it pinches through the sides, it's sitting too much ontop of her. This saddle will cause pain for the morgan if you ride in it...pass for her.
The second horse fits the saddle the best out of the 3 if I absolutely had to pick. It still looks a tad too wide, but not wide enough to hammer down on his withers. It doesn't seem to be pinching anywhere but I'd still really like to see a bit more wither clearance with him.
The arab fits the saddle the worst. Please don't ever ride this horse with this saddle! It is WAY too wide and from my previous reply, will cause serious damage and pain to his back. Pass hardcore for this horse!
I know saddle fitting is frustrating and a lot of people don't understand that a saddle needs to fit pretty much perfect or else you will cause serious harm and damage to your horse's back. It's like finding a pair of shoes...they can't be too small or too big or else they cause blisters, slipping and PAIN. Posted via Mobile Device