I'd go with a 17". And I ride a 14 and 1/2 western.
Danny's Tack Shop doesn't have a website. The Heguy saddle runs $695 new. The number to the shop is 315-696-8036. There are other good ones in that price range. I only gave $200 because I found it in a classifieds newspaper ad from Virginia on about the 12th page of a Google search for used polo saddles. (I love the internet!)
For $200 you can find a decent used polo saddle with years of life left in them. There are also some used ones in town at King's Saddlery, but I haven't checked the prices. They don't sell anything with a broken tree either, but sometimes you pay for the King's name. Or, the name of the player who is selling the saddle.
I'll be in Louisville over Thanksgiving, I'm going to check a store there anyway. If I find a couple I'll pick them up, and if you don't want one we'll donate it to a school. They always can use more tack, horses, gloves...
And I understand that broke phase. I'm in the "broke because I have two in college" period of life!
Last edited by boots; 11-12-2012 at 08:45 PM.