No way! The rasp I bought on sale was from Chick's. I junked that thing so fast, didn't even get a single bit of use out of it. I personally use Bellota top sharp, Heller red tang, or Heller Black Legend. The Black Legend is more suitable to softer feet, fyi. I used it for the first time on a mare that had rock hard feet a couple days ago and had to use the coarse side pretty much the entire time and even then it was like I was using the fine side of a Bellotta rasp on my yearling, who has softer feet. I've yet to use the Red tang rasp, but I can tell it's great quality and will be better for harder hooves. The Bellotta rasp does well for both hard and softer hooves.