IMO both farriers look to be "fitting the hoof to the shoe".
I would not be happy. When my horse was shod, my farrier was able to have him with lateral flares in the fronts and a good 1/2" of shoe out behind to balance the leg and the horse didn't pull one single solitary shoe. And he's not exactly quiet in turnout, nor is he a short strided mover.
I have pics on my phone which I can upload if I need to to show the hooves.
But yeah, your mare is not balanced at all, laterally or longitudinally. I would not be paying any amount of money for either job.
They say money doesn't buy happiness -- well happiness doesn't buy horses!