I don't see anything wrong with this horses confo and not sure why the negative reviews, except for a stud needs a performance record and good bloodlines. If this was a gelding you would be getting fabulous critiques. And 14 is not necessarily too late to geld. I love his front legs, great bone. Neck is gorgeous, great throatlatch, short compact back, maybe a touch straight in the hock. Go look at him. I'm sure he's not stallion quality because he wouldn't be selling for $2500, but as a gelding for what you want, worth a look in my book.