Either one would be too high of a price for my area. I have wonderful, all tested homozygous tobiano, registered APHA, well bred, halter/ridable, showing and jumping and pretty much all around capabilities and my best babies are priced at $2500.00. I agree, the mare isn't aweful, however she also isn't anything special except for her willing nature & training, and she seems to be very out of condition at that. However if someone will pay you that price, more power to you, but I hope they really get what they are expecting. Good luck and God bless.