Did you thin it first? I have seen this time and time again......a mane pulled before its thinned......or the mane is sawn off with a sharp comb, not taken piece by piece which will thin it at the same time....
Did you actually 'pull' it out, or cut it????
The only way to keep it down is to tie thick pieces in bands and pray it lays down on his neck.....
(I was once a pro groom.....done a cazillion manes

)