White-out makes it worse?

I used some Cowboy Magic on my black/white filly and when I started to rub it out...the stain just spread. It looks a lot worse than it did so now I'm confused. Did I do something wrong? What can I do now to make her cleaner? Thanks!

When I use cowboy magic it works beautifully. Did you rub it enough? I'm not sure why it would have made it worse....?

^maybe I used too much or something? Cause when I sprayed it, the dirt started running down her side....

Yeah. The dirt spread. How about try to get her as clean as you can, with maybe a small bath, then wait till she's dry, THEN try it again?

I'm planning on giving her a bath when it gets warmer out. Its been windy constantly lately and chilly. It would be her first bath so I want her to be as comfortable as possible so for now, I'm using green-spot remover. I'm so dumb lol...I put white-out in the title. =)