Why not place a call to the vet on this one? I've given Major whole carrots before too...but as someone pointed out...it may be a whole other thing when it comes to eating them on a regular basis.a friend of mine had a horse in her pasture..the horse lived there for months. She cut down a tree in the pasture and left it. After it died the horse ate the leaves and it ended up killing the horse. Come to find out..the horse eating a few of those dead leaves didnt hurt it..but after it was cut down and the horse had access to the dead leaves all the time..it basically poisoned her. I think it was a cherry tree...although im not sure. The point is (in my long story..sorry) you can't go by whats safe here and there.