Oh wow, Yeah, if that is all you have to pick from I would go with the Safe Choice..I would also get the beet pulp if you can. Your feed store can't order feed for you? I know our's can but you might have to buy more than one or two bags at the time.If your feed store sells Safe Choice they should have a license to sell all Nutrena feeds. If they do and can order it for you, you can also look to different Nutrena feeds besides Safe Choice if it doesn't work out for you, even though it has really worked for both of my horses. Using an oil in their feed can be good for some horses but I would only use an Omega3 oil. I used Dumor Rice Bran oil with Nikki for a while and had good results but there are many brands of it..I think fish oil is actually really good for horses..Just a thought..
And Safe Choice isn't Purina feed..It's Nutrena..
I am Sparkly Meanie Doodie Head and I approve this message!