Question of horse ownership ?
I have a friend, Ann. I've known Ann for a couple years now and she has always had two horses. She was engaged and recently split from the guy. I have seen him once. Her second horse was the horse he would ride when involved with the horses, which was rare. Ann and her teenage son picked up this horse and paid cash for her nearly 3 years ago. She did not get a bill of sale on the mare. I do believe that the ex contributed towards the purchase price of the horse but was not involved in the transaction.
Ann has cared for and treated this horse as her own for the duration of ownership. The ex is not a horseman. Ann paid the monthly pasture rental for both of her horses as well. When Ann and her ex split, she moved the horses to my facility. The previous pasture was 2 blocks from the ex and she did not feel comfortable being there any longer.
In the meantime, the ex( this story is to give insight on his actions) decided to take her boat that was stored in a neutral location. The police were involved and the boat was quickly returned. She has owned the boat for 20 years. Silly man.
Now... He wants the horse!! He wants the money ($250) that he contributed towards her purchase price and plans to sell the mare at auction. (This is disturbing because the local horse auctions here (AL) have a large number of meat buyers.) He has involved local law enforcement. Supposedly, this police investigator has told him that if he can get a bill of sale on the mare, not if he HAS a bill of sale, he would accompany the ex to my horse farm and get her back. Now the ex is currently trying to contact the previous owner to get a bill of sale on the horse so he can come pick her up.
Here is my question. If the ex pulls up at my farm with a law enforcement officer that is not in my farm's jurisdiction, what would be my response? Or if they pull up with local law and a bill of sale that was recently acquired? Would me asking for a court order be a good response if someone shows up at my barn to remove a horse? I am not an active boarding facility but am capable of boarding(I just avoid drama, haha) I do have a boarding agreement with Ann for her two horses and feel I could be her Huckleberry in this situation because the horse in on my property.
In my logical mind, I think this would be a civil issue and a court would have to determine ownership, not law enforcement. Ann has obviously invested way more than his small contribution to price of purchase in this mare over the past three years. My experience with relationships ending is sometimes we take a loss with some things. does anyone have insight on this kind of situation? I sure don't!!