We usually get 3-4 cuttings a year here too. We paid $55 for a round bale around 1200 pounds. That's 2nd cutting Alfalfa.
Our 2nd cutting square bales we paid $3.00 for. They are about 75 pounds. The farmer wanted $3.50 but for some reason, he thought the bales got too dried out (not as green as he likes) and cut the price down for us. His hay is GORGEOUS! I don't know if the bales we got could get better then this but he's very picky about his hay. My mom and I were scratching our heads trying to figure out what he was thinking, LoL. Super nice guy too.
Send some my way we're paying between $14 and $20 a bale for small squares that weigh around 80 to 100 lbs.