The first horse may do ok at the lower levels, but she really pulls her front end down and I don't like the paddling.
I do like the second horse, and depending on what you're looking to do, a heavier horse is fine. I see a lot of heavy WB and draft crosses up to Prelim. It all depends on their bone, conformation and scope.
I think the Paint is cute as a button and probably very versatile, the kind of horse you can change your riding interests with and with minimal training will adapt. Since he's close, I'd def look at him.
If your horse says no, you either asked the wrong question or asked the question wrong
And God took a handful of southerly wind, blew His breath over it and created the horse