I usually use Hydrophane Leather Darkening Oil for my leather, but I was wondering if anyone had suggestions for getting a natural leather to look more redish????... I want to match my saddle
I think if you just used a regular oil, it would darken up, and maybe match a little better. It looks like your bridle already has some red-ish tones to it, they just need to be brought out more.
I would just clean and condition it well, and run a couple of light oil coats over it.