Okay so Duchess will need a saddle of her own eventually. I want something that I can comfortably trail ride in but also do showing in (local open shows, nothing fancy).
My instructor suggested All-Purpose or a Dressage saddle with a wide tree.
Dressage Saddles have nice deep seats and position you where you have a nice open hip angle with a long leg under you. The stirrup bars are placed further back, to encourage this proper riding postion.
All Purposes - there are two different models. One's that lean more towards dressage, and one's that lean more towards Jumping.
Your "Eventing" saddle, are the All Purposes that are geared more towards jumping.
vss=all purpose-emphasis toward jumping, cross country, hunting and eventing vsd=all purpose-emphasis toward dressage, pleasure riding and endurance
The difference between the two, are the knee flaps, and the stirrup bars.
If you want to do primarily dressage, get a dressage saddle.
Mine is actually for sale! I was in a similar situation as you two years ago and opted for an all purpose, and now that I also have a dressage saddle I'm looking to upgrade to a jumping saddle.
The brand is "felton saddlery". They stopped distributing saddles a couple of years ago so they're nearly impossible to find, but I fell in love with it when I tried it and everyone at my barn who's ever ridden in it can't believe how comfortable the brand is for being "unknown". PM me and I can send you more info.
Windtec Is Quite Comfy! There Not Leather Either And They Have A Changeable Tree 2! I Have 1 And Its Been Handy As I Didnt Need 2 Get A New Saddle When My Tb Lost Weight Or When He Put It Back on With Muscle!