Thanks for the input! I ordered a Back in Black headstall and a Desert Blossom headstall from Valley Vet yesterday and then started to wonder if I would be happy with them. But it sounds like I will!
I am not ultra picky or anything, but I like good leather. Even harness leather is great, just not the stiff, cheap stuff. Not that I thought those would be like that, but still, I haven't seen their headstalls in real life.
I kind of got a bit spoiled because my neighbor has several Martin headstalls, and I ended up buying two. I know these won't be that high caliber, because the Martins are really expensive, but just as long as they are quality leather and well made, I will be happy.
I have seen a Smart Cinch or two in person, and they are very nice. I ended up buying a Classic Equine alpaca cinch when I wanted another mohair and I love it so far (I've only had it since Christmas and the weather has been cruddy so I've only ridden with it 3-4 times). I really love nice tack!