Originally Posted by Saddlebag
Definitely bypass the black one and the State Line is iffy. You can't go by reviews as sellers can submit them. To me they are just too cheap and likely asian made. You can't see inside the saddle to know what the tree is made of. I've seen horses go lame wearing poorly constructed saddles.
They may very well be asian made, but let's keep in mind that there are well known brands out there that regularly have their items made in India. Look at Vespucci items.
I like the look of the ebay
one, especially in that it has a tree for an Arabian (if you look at their other listings), but I would probably lean towards Stateline just because they're more well known.