don't waste your money,, Not saying they arnt good saddles but just from your tone you're not going to be happy with it. The big horn, circle y, and fabtron leather/cordura saddles are pretty well made and alot of people especially women seem to like them for their lighter weight. Cordura is expensive and tough but less labor intensive to sew so lower labor costs.
Any time soemthing new comes along you will get nay sayers, Alot of the people you hear putting them down have never rode in them. The specific saddle you mentioned I have heard nothing but good things about. Butttttttttt I just don't like the way they look.
Save some bucks and look at the Dakota walker saddle. They run high 8's and a all leather and nice comfortable saddles.