Never heard of the 1st one. Billy Royals are very good Saddles, Bob's a touch over priced for what you get.
Fit is all about the Tree you order, all custom Saddles generally have multiple choices on trees.
Thanks! Yes, the Bobs I'm looking at looks a bit 'plain' for the money. Vic Bennett is kind of a household name (in a reiners house!) in Alberta. He hand made a lot of saddles and is a rider himself. Ok, I might look at the Billy Royal a little more closely.....however it has a rough out seat, I prefer a slick seat....but will give it a shot anyway. Here's a link to Vic Bennett if your curious.