Okay, so I finally bought my own horse, and she is current being ridden in a tom thumb. I would like to change her bit into something less hard. So my question is what kind of bit would be good for neck-reining? Would a french link work? Or do I need something else. I am not opposed to spending $50 or more on a bit. But I would like to find a cheaper bit to order and buy when I am trying it out.
My other question in short. What is the propose of a noseband?
You can neck rein in any bit, or even with no bit at all! Western horses are shown up in the bridle with shanks with one hand, but it doesn't matter. You can do it in a french link if you want. The shank bits are just favored because you can give quieter signals on a looser rein. But really, if your horse is trained, it doesn't matter. I school in a snaffle and will ride one handed with one.
Secondly, by a noseband, I assume you mean the western kind. I use it for two reasons:
1. On the trail so I can tie up without having the halter underneath
Or 2. For the tiedown in barrel racing to help a horse balance in turns.
For a horse that neck reins well, you can ride in either a snaffle or a curb of some sort. You can find shanked bits that either have a dogbone or french link mouth on them, but I am not a fan of shanked bits with broken and/or floating mouths like that. I much prefer something solid that my horses can pick up and carry instead of just packing around.
As for nosebands, it depends on what kind you're talking about as there are several different things that are all called "nosebands" in the western world.
There are tie-downs, which are nosebands attached to the front cinch via a strip of leather/nylon. Those are designed for horses to brace against them in high torque events like roping and barrels so that a horse can maintain balance and strength in a sharp turn or a hard stop.
Then, there are bosalitas, which are often used with a "get-down" rope. I can't seem to find a good picture of one on a horse but they look like this. The rope is tied around the horse's neck at the throatlatch then run through the rawhide noseband. They are traditionally used on ranch and/or vaquero horses for leading/tying instead of using the bridle reins.
Then, there are cavesons. Basically, they are a noseband designed to try to keep the horse quiet on the bit...though I think they are more of a crutch than anything in that regard. IMHO, there are much better and much more effective ways to get a quiet horse, but that's beside the point. They are just strips of leather/rope/rawhide with or without decoration that are not designed to withstand any sort of pressure from leading/tying/tie-down/etc. They are used almost exclusively with snaffle bits.