I got a saddle off Craigslist. It is a Circle Y synthetic. I paid $250 with shipping.
It was advertised as a 19 inch in great shape.
It came yesterday and is a 17 inch with gouges and scratches.
I emailed the seller and sent pics of the measurements and scratches and have not heard back from them (of course).
I paid through paypal, should I do a chargeback? Do I have to prove I sent it back (delivery conformation) to do that?