My daughter rode on a Stubben Edelweis jumping saddle with her first lease horse. She LOVED it for its soft seat and it fit a tough to fit horse. I then bought her a used Carlye on consignment as her first saddle and it was fine for a while. The benefit from a consignment or tack shop over ebay
is that if it isn't comfortable or doesn't fit the horse right, you usually have 7 days to return it. She has used the Carlyle for a year and it looks beautiful, but now that she is jumping more she complains it is uncomfortable. We just saw a used Stubbem Edelweis on ebay and the pictures looked excellent. It had a great Buy It Now price so we took the chance and ordered it. Now I am obsessing about whether it will really be OK since there are big differences even within the Stubben Edelweis line based on when it was made, size, slight design modifications etc. Maybe we will be lucky and it will turn out as well as it looked on ebay. If not, I am prepared to get it reflocked or resell it if it isn't right. I would have paid more for it on consignment but there is something to be said for peace of mind.
All that being said, I think we are Stubben fans! I am not familiar with the model you are looking at but I think they make a quality product.