I like Troxels and have not had any of the problems mentioned above. I'm on my 3rd Troxel helmet. I bought a velvet covered helmet (don't remember the style) first that had the dial fit. I had this helmet for about 8 years before I had a fall bad enough to break it. The next one I bought was a black western style Cheyenne with the GPS III fit. While I liked the helmet itself, it got to be too hot in the summer to wear. I replaced it with the Sierra with the cinch fit. I LOVE this helmet. It is soooo comfortable. I am a Troxel fan.
That being said, everyone has their own favorite. The most important thing is does it fit your head. Try on several brands and different styles if they are available at your local shop. You may find one fits better than another. Go with what ever is the best fit for you.
"SUCCESS is not what horse you have . . . but what you do with that horse."