1 - used (and by used, I liken it to a "used" car with about 500 miles on it -- you get used price and new quality) Circle Y Flex2 Topeka.
2 - new High Horse (all leather, don't like cordura).
The price would pretty much be a wash, option one *might* end up being $50-100 more depending on whether they accept my offer (the consignments are all open to offers)