I would be wary of that. Everything sounds the same when you're reading it "this saddle fit my horse, and she's not the most fit" it just sounds too, played up. Not to mention people from stateline could have written it and just done have it said there were from different locations.
Not to mention besides the one written in december of 07, all the other ones were all within a month of each other. It just seems odd to me.
I always found horsetackreview.com to be a great place to get reviews of horse products