Yeah, seems very suspicious to me! That set looks like a piece of garbage!
I heard recently that some companies who sell on Amazon.com were being sued for posting complimentary "reviews" of their products on the site. Something to do with it being fraudulent because they are not true, honest, unbiased reviews vs. that it's simply "product description."
I'd be curious to see they would post a more realistic review of this saddle set if one of us were to submit one. Something along the lines of, "Great value for $150, but didn't hold up to daily use." Or maybe they only post the good ones.
Yeah...I wouldn't exactly trust comments like this as coming from the best kind of horsepeople.
I agree, either a couple of people got VERY lucky, they're just not that good at judging when a saddle fits/their horse is happy or they're plants.