Haha, I guess I'm one of those people who "swear" by the combination bandages. Although I use regular polo wraps when I'm actually playing polo, I love that they give my horse pretty good leg support and protection, and because they're not entirely elastic you don't have to worry about "over tightening" the wraps.
I use these "Nest Bandages
" from horze, and they've proven to be pretty durable (more so than the plain cotton ones I use for polo, which frequently get rips and holes after frequent use). Good luck!~