I have had a new Rocking R (under the label of Bar J for a local tack shop) and an older one. I really liked them both, but the older one is much more comfortable. I really love it. In fact-I just bought a new (used) saddle, and am really debating whether I will use it enough for the price I paid.
So, Go with the Rocking R, would be be recommendation of these 2.
I just checked the place (a small used saddle dealer) where I got mine. She was very fair and nice, and I felt I got a good deal. Even traded a couple saddle to do the deal with her. Anyway-she has a Tex Tan, which also looks good. THe Rocking R she has is a reining saddle, Like I have and the cantle is lower. Used Saddles - Shells Saddle Shack