The Crosby Equilibrium (used) didn't fit me. I can't remember what was wrong with it. I think the flap wasn't right for my leg and left my knee sticking out in front.
The Ovation QH (used, but only 6 times) was as nice in person as it is in the picture online, but the seat is too small for me. The saddle is stamped 17.5 but measures 17 on the nose. I suggested perhaps it had been mis-stamped? Anyway, apparently I need a 17.5 saddle so that one didn't work either.
Then I sat in both the M. Toulouse Lucia II and the Padjette (new, and for some reason half price on clearance). Of the two I liked the Padjette better, and the store owner who was helping me thought that I looked better in it than the Lucia II. Soooooo I took a Padjette on trial and sent it with my friend to the barn so she can put it on my horse's back and see how it fits him. The store's trial policy is only two days, so hopefully if it fits him I'll feel up to sitting in it ON the horse tomorrow evening so we can see how things look with 135# of me weighing it down.
The skeptic in my head says no way can it be this easy, so we'll see what happens.
Here's info on the Padjette from the Intec website (M. Toulouse is one of the Intec brands), for anyone who is curious: