I would like to suggest checking out the Rocky R brand. I have their training saddle and an equitation show saddle from them and just love them. I used to own a circle y saddle and I personally didnt like how it fit my horse. I have attached a picture from the catalog. The saddle is priced around $850 (give or take do a search on the internet)
It weighs around 35lbs but is very sturdy. Never had any horse problems with it either. I had to turn the stirups out though when I first got it. But love it.
I own the bottom right (2380) they are roughed out which helps "stick" if need be. I don't personally like smooth seats. Hope this helps