I honestly don't believe tall boots vrs 1/2 chaps really make a difference as to "support" for the leg while in the saddle.
Your legs should be strong enough throgh proper riding and conditioning of your muscles, to remain where they should and to do their jobs accoringly.
I have used 1/2 chaps, and never found any difference between them and tall boots via support wise.
But, I dislike 1/2 chaps and paddock boots - because I hate the work involved on getting them on and off. I hate to have to sit down, put on my paddocks and then struggle with getting my 1/2 chaps on. And then repeat when getting them off.
I love my tall boots, with zippers because they are much more convenient for me. I just slide my foot in my boots, zip up and done. Out the door.
I find my other short boots make my foot slip out of the stirrup and my top boots have no slips at all,and keep my heels down.
I just prefer the feel of them.
Yes iam learning about leg postions and it takes alot of work to ride properly and iam still learning lol
I only bought the top boots a few days ago and they just feel so much better to me.And the putting them on annoys me too,ive only been wearing half chaps for a few months because everyone said how comfortable they are but I went back to top boots,easier to put on.
I suppose to experienced riders like yourself it doesnt make a difference but to me it just makes my foot and leg feel more secure.
Depends on what i'm in the mood for. If I'm doing barn work and riding, I'm all about my half chaps and paddock boots because that's easier and I don't care if they get dirty or muddy. If I have a clinic or demonstration to do or am riding all day, then I like my tall boots b/c they are comfortable and look nicer. As for riding, I don't thin either really effects how I ride, just a matter of preference for what else I may have going on that day.
I love my half chaps and wear them every time I ride! They fit like a glove and sometimes I drive all the way home from the barn before I realize I still have them on! I have tall boots but only wear them in preparation for shows to get used to them.