Both horses: Leather ThinLine halters
in dark brown (I like leather halters, they're more classy and last longer), whatever lead rope is attached (they both have the same size head), whatever saddle blanket is clean, and we don't use boots or polos
Now, "I" have my color preferences. I like dark blue and green, so most of my gear (that comes in colors) is hunter, navy, or royal, but there's no real pattern to it, lol. I'll use a royal saddle pad with a hunter green saddle bag <GASP!!> lol.