Originally Posted by Speed Racer
None of them are in very good shape. They don't look as if they've been well cared for over the years.
You'd be lucky to get $100 for the red one, $50.00 for the English, and nothing for the third. That one looks especially bad. I don't think even cleaning and oiling it would help at this point.
I disagree. The "red" and the English AP are in typical condition for used saddles. The red saddle would be priced at $250 to $295 in my local tack shops. The AP is an import, and would be priced around $75 to $80 without fittings.
The last saddle needs fenders and stirrup leathers and stirrups to be usable. From what I can see, it the leather holding the rigging dees is still good, that saddle would be repairable. As-is, it might only get $25 to $50. Repaired with some appropriate leather fenders, maybe $275 or so.
That's just my guess.