Personally when I first switched from Western to english I was thrown right into a jumping saddle. Luckily I was young and stubborn so I just did as I was told. I know for me when it comes to overall comfort, I LOVE my wintec all purpose for "hanging out" and flat work. I have a courbette dressage saddle that is my "cadillac" saddle. I feel like it has a lot more to it and really "holds me in" I use this one for training when I am with a new horse, just because I feel safest and have the best leg position/ contact. I still ride western also, but figure my opinion on that isn't relevant to this convo lol! :)
"A horse is eleven-hundred pounds of raw muscle, power, and grace between your legs! It's something you just can't get from a pet hamster!"