Originally Posted by franknbeans
Recently got a 5-star. LOVE IT! So soft and wonderful! I also wanted the close contact shape, which it doesn't look like the others offer.
I don;t know anything about the others.
Yes I get a lot of good reviews on 5 stars. I rode in a Tod Slone and it worked perfectly (I guess tod slone and 5 star used to be the same company), and there is a 5 star at my barn, and while moving it I felt that it was really soft. The tod slone is a little harder, but not really in a bad way, I will be using like an under pad or blanket underneath it. I don't think many people have experience with the Best ever pads because it is a newer company.