Originally Posted by kitten_Val
I agree with mls. Good quality + fit the horse + fit the butt. You may end up with not-so-common brand still a great saddle for everyone.
I liked Billy Cook when I tried while back, but if I'm not mistaking there are 2 Billy Cooks (made in different state), and one is a good quality, one not so (hopefully someone will give more info as I rely on my memory only :) ).
The Sulphur, OK saddles are the better quality ones and the Greenville, TX ones are the not so good ones.