Treeless Saddles

       The Horse Forum > Keeping and Caring for Horses > Horse Talk

Treeless Saddles

This is a discussion on Treeless Saddles within the Horse Talk forums, part of the Keeping and Caring for Horses category

LinkBack Thread Tools
    03-01-2007, 06:33 PM
Treeless Saddles

Okay... I posted in another section of the form under the same title, but I didn't get much responce (only one person). This is what I wrote in the previous posting:

[i] I am looking to buy a treeless saddle... I was pretty sure I wanted a Bob Marshall, and ordered one, but there were complications and I never received my saddle. Anyway, I've been searching on eBay for a Bob Marshall treeless... I've also found another company who does treeless saddles--Barefoot. Their saddles look like good quality, but I am hoping that maybe someone has ridden in one or has personnally seen one and can tell me what they're like???
Also, what about the Circle Y Bob Marshall treeless? A friend of mine told me to stay away from those kind, but why?

Any information you could give me would be fabulous! Thanks!!! (I hope I get more responces this time!!! )
Sponsored Links
    03-01-2007, 09:46 PM
I haven't ridden in one myself but i've seen them and talked to someone about them.
They are really comfortable and help you kept really close contact with your horse when your riding.
I have also been told that they aren't very good for heavy riders because they don't have a tree to distribute weight on the horses back evenly. If you are a light person they should be fine for you.
Treeless saddles aslo fit a horses back very well and would be comfortable for you and your horse if you aren't a heavy person.
    03-03-2007, 11:26 AM
I don't know where you posted or if I was the one that answerd but I have stated not only my opinion of these pieces of junk but by experts I have quoted. A saddle tree is dsigned to distribute the weight on the top of the rib cage. A treeless puts the weight directly on the spine. They will cause back problems and also tend to make a horses kidneys sore. Like I said this is not only my opinion but taken from reserch I have done with Veteranarians that specialize in this kind of trouble.
    03-03-2007, 10:38 PM
Desert rat, I didn't see the post. Can you give me a link to it or more info?
    03-04-2007, 04:43 PM
Kristy i've been looking for the artical by the vetrenarins on the treeless saddles. I thought I had it on favorites but it must be on my other puter up at the summer place. I'll keep looking though. National Bridal Shop has a real nice light solid tree ( fiberglass ) for gated horses that is a real good sevicable saddle that is also a real comfortable saddle. My wife sold her mule saddle because it was just too heavy and bought one for her mustang. She is real pleased with it and even on long rides she never gets tired or sore from it.
    03-04-2007, 05:05 PM
Kristy here is some info you may find interesting. Even though it is on English saddles the function of the tree is all the same and you can see how important a solid tree is for weight distrabution. I'll keep looking for the vet page on what damage can come from treeless saddles.

Principles of Correct Saddle Fit
Saddle Fit: Understanding the basics
Saddle Fit: A word about panel design and technology

Saddle Fit: Understanding the basics - Tree, Panels, and Motion
The basic principles of saddle fitting are relatively easy to understand. The primary principles of saddle fitting are analogous to fitting your foot correctly in a pair of supportive athletic shoes. A well-fitting saddle spreads the rider's weight-per-square-inch evenly over the panels, avoiding excessive or uneven pressure under any part of the tree or panels. The saddle must also be correctly balanced so that neither the back nor front is either perched too high or wedged too low.

Front and back gussets enable the panel
To be shaped for even weight distribution
And correct balance.

The purpose of the tree is to distribute the rider’s weight as evenly as possible over the broad, strong sweep of muscular surface of the horse's back. The tree is also designed to protect the crucially sensitive spine and central nervous system from impact shock or pressure. The panel that the saddle sits on cushions the tree, helps to balance the saddle, and provides a close, stable purchase between the saddle and the horse’s back. In order to achieve correct balance for the rider and even distribution of weight for the horse, the tree must be the correct width, and of vital importance, the tree must be the correct shape for the horse.

The tree points must be a reasonable match for the angle of the horse's shoulder. This aspect of tree fit is relatively easy to assess, and often the investigation delves no deeper than this. What is harder to discern is whether the other dimensions of the tree are equally well-matched to the shape of the horse’s body. Once the tree is covered by the seat on top and the panels below, the exact fit characteristics of a particular tree are often more challenging to work out. It is quite helpful if the fitter has some familiarity with the overall shape and dimensions of the particular tree in question to be confident that the structural contours of the tree are a close match for the contours of the horse’s body.

If, for example, the space between the rails of the tree is too narrow for a horse with a short, dome-shaped wither, the saddle will pinch and pivot over the stirrup bars. One clue to this might be that the back of the saddle tends to flip up and down in rising trot. In this instance, if the spacing of the rails is too narrow or angular for the width and spread of a particular horse’s back, the narrow area under the stirrup bars forms a sort of stricture where the contour of the tree deviates significantly from the contour of the horse’s back. As the rider weights the stirrup bars, this becomes like a fulcrum, levering the back of the saddle up and down when the horse is in motion. The visual effect may be somewhat disguised either by thick gusseted panels or by trying to level the back panels with a riser pad, but nothing can compensate for the underlying problem of a tree whose shape is a poor match for the horse under the stirrup bars, even if it the fit appears to be a fine through the tree points.

There are many factors that can affect whether a particular saddle remains stable on the horse through the horse’s full range of motion, but the first question to ask is: Does the shape of the tree in this saddle conform well in all its dimensions to the shape of the horse’s back?

What is crucial when evaluating a horse for saddle fitting purposes is not really whether the saddle looks like a good fit when the horse is standing in the cross ties, but what happens when the horse is in motion under a rider. The saddle must be stable and well balanced through the entire range of equine bio-dynamics in order to perform its two critical functions of protecting the spine and distributing the rider's weight comfortably and evenly.


Back to Top

Saddle Fit: A word about panel design and technology
A correctly fitting tree is vital, but so are correctly fitting panels. In general, the larger, broader and more level the weight-bearing surface (as opposed to curvy and dome-shaped), the more comfortable the horse will be in his saddle and the more stable the panel will be when the horse is in motion. From the horse's standpoint, a stable, yielding panel makes the prospect of rounding and engaging the back for correct athletic movement a great deal more inviting.

This gusseted back panel distributes
The rider's weight evenly over the
Horse's back muscles.

Panels are cut on many different patterns with different fit characteristics. What is important to maintaining good support, correct balance, and even weight distribution is that the entire surface of the panel must conform in shape and angulation to the contours of the horse's back when the horse is engaged and on the aides. The saddle fitter's challenge is to choose a panel pattern that will complement the shape of the back while accommodating the changing contours of the horse as he moves through the full range of motion under saddle. This is why it is impossible to make a full and definitive evaluation of correct saddle fit with the horse standing in the aisle.

An expressive, big-moving horse may put considerable dynamic stress on the stability of the saddle. As he engages the large muscles of the back and rounds up under the saddle, he transmits the enormous power of the hindquarters through the spine into forward momentum. Regardless of how well a saddle may seem to fit when the horse is unmounted and at rest, the picture may be quite different when an athletic horse is engaged and on the aids. Even a saddle that appears to fit quite well may end up pivoting and surfing all over the back when put to the acid stability test. In some instances it is obvious in the course of a ride that the saddle has inched forward over the shoulders and therefore is not stable. This is a situation that frustrates many riders on wide, barrel-shaped horses with expressive gaits. Admittedly this type of horse provides the saddle fitter a challenge in stabilizing the saddle, though starting with the best possible shape in the tree is a crucial first step. There are auxiliary design features in the girthing configuration and panels that can also be helpful.

The situation may actually be grimmer, however, for a horse with a more hollow contour around the withers and behind the scapula who is laboring under an unstable saddle. Rather than sliding over the shoulder, the saddle may continuously jam against the back of the shoulder, or bounce around behind on hard, round panels.

If at the end of a ride the saddle is still where the rider put it, the unstable panels or ill-fitting tree may not be visually apparent to the rider. Thus a less-than-stellar performance caused by a poorly-fitting saddle is often attributed to training issues or some other cause. Bear in mind the close analogy between saddles for horses and shoes for human athletes. Imagine a top athlete running a marathon in a pair of penny loafers that are a size too small. With sufficient grit it could be done, but not particularly well.

A skilled saddle fitter must have in-depth understanding of equine biodynamics and a capacity for seeing and evaluating what a horse does with his back and body with a rider aboard. In the same way that human athletes are unique and idiosyncratic in how they perform athletically, horses are as well. Many of the classic problems in fitting performance horses require understanding not only how a particular horse is put together conformationally, but how the horse in question engages his back, how straight or crooked he moves in various gaits, how well balanced he is longitudinally and laterally. However well a saddle may appear to fit when the horse is standing in the cross ties, what matters is the dynamic effect the combination of horse and rider have on the stability and balance of the saddle is when the horse is on the aids.


Back to Top

© Copyright 2004, 2006 Advanced Saddle Fit, LLC All Rights Reserved - Legal | Privacy | Shipping | Returns | Contact

Home | About | Contact | Saddle Fitting | Saddlery: Custom Fit | Equestrian Saddle Fit Process | Saddles | Saddle Pads | Bridles | Tack: Reins
Horse Tack: Girths | Stirru
    03-11-2007, 06:30 PM
I considered treeless for my boy, but decided against it. I know a lot of people who have gone treeless and had a lot of sucsess with it. But as with any saddle it still needs to be fitted to your horse. Not all horses can wear a treeless saddle, contrary to belief.

You have to use a special pad with treeless saddles other wize the weight of the rider is right on the spine.

A lot of treeless saddles they are making nowadays have padding either side of the center, creating a gullet, so the weight of the rider is evenly distributed.

I don't know that much about treeless saddles, I decided against it in the end as I felt it was going to be too expensive and I was going to have to entirly re-kit my pony as not only can you not user a normal saddle pad with them, you have to use a dressage girth as well.

My boy is getting a wintec 500 in april. It's a synthetic saddle that is leather look with exchangable gullets so should he change shape, or should I get another pony, that saddle can be made to fit another.
    03-11-2007, 09:16 PM
What kind of saddle pad do they use?
    03-14-2007, 05:05 PM
If you look here, at the bottom of the page it has a few of the special saddle pads... they are very expensive! Making it a huge outlay to get yourself kitted out for treeless.

Quick Reply
Please help keep the Horse Forum enjoyable by reporting rude posts.

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the The Horse Forum forums, you must first register.

Already have a Horse Forum account?
Members are allowed only one account per person at the Horse Forum, so if you've made an account here in the past you'll need to continue using that account. Please do not create a new account or you may lose access to the Horse Forum. If you need help recovering your existing account, please Contact Us. We'll be glad to help!

New to the Horse Forum?
Please choose a username you will be satisfied with using for the duration of your membership at the Horse Forum. We do not change members' usernames upon request because that would make it difficult for everyone to keep track of who is who on the forum. For that reason, please do not incorporate your horse's name into your username so that you are not stuck with a username related to a horse you may no longer have some day, or use any other username you may no longer identify with or care for in the future.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

Old Thread Warning
This thread is more than 90 days old. When a thread is this old, it is often better to start a new thread rather than post to it. However, If you feel you have something of value to add to this particular thread, you can do so by checking the box below before submitting your post.

Thread Tools

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:27 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0