I'll try these whenever I can. There is snow in the ground, so horses arent being turned out :( I know I shouldn't use treats but she'll walk up to me and if I don't have a treat she will run away. When she runs away I just walk slowly near her or stand still. She also doesn't care about the other horses in the field (she is pretty anti social!) lol, if they come in she'll just go to the other end of the field. I will try the whip trick
Also at the moment she isn't being to bad but will come only to me if I have grain, no one else can catch her.