I obviously don't know what a "bitless bridle" so if anyone wants to explain that to me that would be great.
For me riding bitless would be in a rope halter or in a bosal. Riding in a bosal is an art in itself to achieve results.Basically riding in a bosal is bluffing a horse in a way. Once he learns he can push through it you've ruined it. And the same is with a halter. You have to have the respect. However I am not saying you get from a bit. Same with a bit, if you pull on the same area constantly you numb that area and you have to pull harder to get those same results. I see so many people riding in the bosal and never change the position on the nose or never have it adjusted properly to begin with! Let alone using it correctly and they just end up with a hard faced run away. Buying a good bosal isn't easy either, you have to know what to look for and want to spend the money on it. Instead of buying some cable core POS for $30 at the feedstore. When done correctly a hackamore horse can have more finesse than a bridle horse believe it or not. And I don't think most people have the knowledge to accomplish that....not saying that I do, but I have been learning.
I am not an advocate of most people riding with a bosal or halter all the time because I have seen more wrecks than anything else. I worked for a cowboss who would fire you if you rode out of the saddle barn with a bosal hanging on your horse to go doctor yearlings just for that reason. Here you are with a 700 lb steer on the end of your rope and there is dip **** trying to pull up Brownie in his hackamore rig to get close enough to get a heel shot in. But if you wanted to ride your horse in the pens at the barn and do a little training on one that was fine with him. I can ride and rope with a halter or bosal on all my horses, but do I do it all the time..no. I realize that most people are not going to be outside roping wild Mexican steers in a hackamore so I am sure its fine for most folks.
I sounded off earlier in this thread without really thinking but now I think
It's not really a matter of using a bit or not, but rather gaining the respect and responses from your horse that is desired. And if you have abilities to do so that is great!
Again I am speaking about bosal/hackamores(NOT the metal contraption hackamore-that is not a hackamore!) and rope halters. I have no idea about a "bitless bridle" or what it is and how to use one.
Vettech- good explanation of true collection and false headsets!