The stages of Training to Reach Collection - Page 4
   

       The Horse Forum > Training Horses > Horse Training

The stages of Training to Reach Collection

This is a discussion on The stages of Training to Reach Collection within the Horse Training forums, part of the Training Horses category

    Like Tree64Likes

     
    LinkBack Thread Tools
        06-21-2013, 12:06 PM
      #31
    Green Broke
    Quote:
    There is nothing wrong with wanting to train a horse to move with greater collection. Most do that to some minor extent. I have, with Mia & Trooper, and I'm a beginning rider who doesn't compete in anything. But the degree to which I need it is minimal, to the point that it doesn't require a training scale or significant effort.
    And the day when you decide to put in significant effort and you get on that horse and your do a maneuver and it feels like all you did was think about it and you and the horse did it.. you will know why people who train horses put in that significant effort. I hope you get that chance because at that moment you will become more than Xenophen.. more than anything.. you will be a centaur.

    Not to disparage your work or your thoughts but this explains a LOT about your posts. Learned from reading (which I do applaud) and observing (which is also admirable) but not from doing.

    I made a bit of living on horse back and training young horses (starting them and then letting them go on to someone else to be finished). This is not to say I "know it all" (that would be boring) but I know a good bit.

    Going back to the beginning. That nice working cow horse. He does not have the same "classical frame" as a dressage horse but if he is efficient and balanced, he will have learned a good bit of "dressage" but it will be less obvious.

    Look at these two videos. If you cannot see both horses have learned the same lessons watch them again.. and again... and again... The western horses have learned to collect, and to balance and to work off their hind quarters and raise the root of their neck as have the dressage horses. Interesting when the riders change horses in the one video...



    Sahara and Skyseternalangel like this.
         
    Sponsored Links
    Advertisement
     
        06-21-2013, 12:37 PM
      #32
    Trained
    "And the day when you decide to put in significant effort and you get on that horse and your do a maneuver and it feels like all you did was think about it and you and the horse did it.. you will know why people who train horses put in that significant effort."

    Sorry, but I HAVE put significant effort into training a horse (5 years), and been happy with the results, without using a training scale designed for dressage. I do not train for collection because the terrain I ride in doesn't reward collection. Nor do my goals require collection.

    Not all training does or should include training for collection. That is the point of the debate.

    " Learned from reading (which I do applaud) and observing (which is also admirable) but not from doing."

    On the contrary. Most of what I know has been learned by doing it with my horses, and seeing how they respond. Frankly, what I see in many experienced riders is that they accept what they were told when learning without questioning - particularly among dressage fans.

    Riding a horse with contact on the bit is not required. A natural headset, as used by the Cavalry, is a "proper" and "balanced" way of riding. Neck reining is a "proper" way of riding, although not 'on the bit'.

    "The western horses have learned to collect, and to balance and to work off their hind quarters and raise the root of their neck as have the dressage horses."

    And if someone wants to teach them that, it is OK. It is not required for a horse to move balanced, or be responsive, or strong. It will not increase their lifespan.

    Science trumps tradition. So does logic. A horse moving with suspension is working harder to move than a horse without. If the goal is to look pretty, that is fine. Ballet is fine, but it isn't how I move around in my life. Too much work, too little reward. I don't want my horse to work hard covering a little ground. I don't want them to carry themselves in a way that works best in an arena. I want them to move fluidly, and efficiently.

    What puzzles me is why some dressage fans think a horse moving inefficiently is more desirable, OUTSIDE OF SOME SPORTS, than one moving efficiently and fluidly.

    BTW - I also don't train my horse to do sliding stops. Nor do I train them to do 360 degree spins. Reining is fun to watch, but doesn't apply to the world my horses and I live in.





    In our world, anything that makes the foot land harder is bad. A horse that doesn't think where it is about to put each foot is bad. In this environment, the horses LIKE pavement. Pavement is easier on their feet. Pavement is level. Trails are not. Pavement doesn't have gullies. Trails do. Pavement doesn't come with cactus inches from your legs. Trails do. It is hot, and there will be no water for the horses until we get back. Efficiency is critical. Looking impressive for the spectators...not so much!

    This is not the world of jumpers. It is not the world of dressage. It is a world that requires strength, balance, control, responsiveness - but not collection.
    FaydesMom likes this.
         
        06-21-2013, 01:31 PM
      #33
    Super Moderator
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Kotori    
    I've read through this twice and I'm still confused. What are you guys debating exactly?
    Posted via Mobile Device


    That is a good question. I am not sure we are all debating the same thing.
    Beling and Skyseternalangel like this.
         
        06-21-2013, 02:32 PM
      #34
    Yearling
    In a nutshell:

    BSMS - collection is only relevant in an arena on a dressage horse and has no real use or value on the trail.

    Elana - all horses can benefit from the basic training foundation that the principles of dressage are built on.
         
        06-21-2013, 02:34 PM
      #35
    Super Moderator
    Thank you. That sounds pretty comprehensible. I got lost in the details.
         
        06-21-2013, 02:48 PM
      #36
    Super Moderator
    Forgive me if I'm getting this wrong but Elana began the thread so those of us interested in using the basic concepts that are the foundation of the dressage sport horse can discuss how useful they can be in other riding disciplines and also how they are already used and often without people realizing it
    If people aren't interested or see no point in it - then they can say so and move on - no problem with that but I'm struggling to see the point in someone repeatedly making their own case for why its a waste of time when they have likely never even ridden a horse that knows how to work in a collected frame so can't make a comparison.
    I bought a horse a recently that had no clue about collection or using her back end and she was dreadful out on the trails, her 'jog' would shake your teeth out and rattle your bones, a year later with some basic dressage schooling she's as smooth as can be and a pleasure to ride - also 100% safer.
    bsms - we get it - you don't see any point in!!!!
    updownrider likes this.
         
        06-21-2013, 02:51 PM
      #37
    Trained
    From my perspective, the debate would be on the question:

    "Does 'training a horse to have the balance and muscles to collect will improve that horse for ANY discipline.. from trails to reining to barrel racing to jumping'?"

    It could be rephrased:

    "Does a "diagram [that] shows the stages of training to go from a green horse with rhythm to a horse that understands how to raise the root of his neck and get his hind quarters under him" apply to all horses? Should all horses train to carry more weight on the rear with a rider than they do without a rider?

    Or it could be rephrased as "Does training in ballet help you when jogging?"
         
        06-21-2013, 03:12 PM
      #38
    Weanling
    ...maybe not jogging, but I remember when ballet was supposed to improve basketball playing.

    I think the attitude bsms has is, "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" is fine if all you want to do is be carried around on horseback. Let the horse be himself, let him figure it out.

    Same as, high school being unnecessary for someone who lays bricks for a living.

    But formal schooling, like following a training scale, is more than just the tasks at hand. There's discipline involved, a heightened ability for communication, and other intangibles, aside from enjoyment.

    Maybe it's just about the quality of life.
         
        06-21-2013, 03:20 PM
      #39
    Super Moderator
    I don't think that you can answer the question
    Will some basic dressage training improve my horse in other aspects of riding - including trail riding
    Unless you actually see the difference for yourself by giving it a try
    To totally simplify things - Its not that much different to asking someone if they prefer apples to oranges when they've never eaten an orange or someone saying they hate apples but have never actually tasted one
         
        06-21-2013, 03:59 PM
      #40
    Super Moderator
    Quote:
    Originally Posted by Kotori    
    I've read through this twice and I'm still confused. What are you guys debating exactly?
    Posted via Mobile Device
    Now, I have NO idea. Bsms won't use multi-quotes so his post is very difficult to follow and he seems to be talking in circles.

    My post to him was directly addressing his post that said, and I quote;

    Quote:
    Dressage is not thousands of years old. Dressage is hundreds of years old, and was intended to train a horse to look good on parade grounds.
    I posted to say that "dressage" ie training, was around MUCH longer, and was meant to make a horse (originally) more supple and responsive for war use.

    Not sure where he went after that.....
    jaydee likes this.
         

    Thread Tools

    Similar Threads
    Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
    How do I get him to reach in the canter? MudPaint Dressage 6 09-08-2011 06:55 PM
    The 8 stages of riding franknbeans Horse Talk 6 04-19-2011 07:53 AM
    Training for collection AQHA Horse Training 8 06-22-2010 04:31 AM
    collection training prince Horse Training 1 05-19-2009 10:44 AM
    Stages jknight Horse Breeding 5 06-12-2008 12:28 AM



    All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:40 AM.


    Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
    Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
    Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0