I like the second one. Only because...I would caution you about the first....I have 2 of these. Ring Mouth Snaffle :: Downunder Horsemanship
Where the silver is overlayed onto the part of the bit that is at the corner of the mouth one of them is a bit rough. It made my horse sore. I would just be careful about that. If you DO decide on one like this, make extra sure when you get it that it is really smooth. Otherwise, I do like mine, and it was great for making him nice and soft and initial training. He now neck reins well, so no snaffle needed any more.