I bought an all purpose saddle 5 months ago, but now I totally regret it. It's fine for jumping in hunters/cross country, but now I need a dressage saddle for eventing which my all purpose isn't exactly ideal for. And I figure when I get my dressage saddle I might as well trade in my all purpose for a close contact... so it really depends on what you want to get in to now, and what you see yourself doing in the near future. Jumpers, hunters or eventing?
Do you live near a saddle fitter?