Too big for your horse short-term damage or ok for a little while? - Page 2
 
 

       The Horse Forum > The Horse Forum Community > Plus Sized Riders

Too big for your horse short-term damage or ok for a little while?

This is a discussion on Too big for your horse short-term damage or ok for a little while? within the Plus Sized Riders forums, part of the The Horse Forum Community category

    Like Tree60Likes

     
    LinkBack Thread Tools
        07-22-2013, 03:17 PM
      #11
    Green Broke
    Weight percents have ZERO basis in scientific fact, simple as that. Anyone with the ability to grasp basic logic should be able to see that. So lets see my in shape super conditioned 50 mile horse at 900 lbs can carry less weight than he can now soft and lazy at a 1000 lbs ? Really ? So an 1500lb draft horse with arthritis and a bad back can carry more than an 800 lb arab ? Wow good to know.
    FACT over a 10 year study at tevis, (100 mile very hard endurance event) study found ZERO correlation between horse weight and rider weight in completion %, winning %, or pull %, up to and including riders at 32%.Confirmation and preride condition did.
    FACT in an era when the average horse was barely 14 hands and probably 800 on a good day. A "Horse weight" was a unit of measure equal to 200 lbs. Used by people who's livlyhood depended on sound horses.
    In that era the actual combat horses again 14 hands, were carrying armor and armored soldiers into combat. The giant chargers are a myth. And only used in parades. Actual war horses based on actual stored horse armor again, 14 handish.
    Percents, Not a rule of thumb, Not a guideline, Not anything. Simply regurgitated nonsense. Has as much basis in the real world as saying a brown horse can carry more than a white.

    Now Im not saying that horse can or can't carry you or anyone else, what I am saying is that his weight has nothing to do with it.
         
    Sponsored Links
    Advertisement
     
        07-22-2013, 04:03 PM
      #12
    Showing
    In this instance, I agree completely with Joe. While it is possible to overload a horse and, with the type of riding I do that includes roping and dragging heavy cattle, I'd be resistant to going over 30% just for my own peace of mind.

    However, just for average riding, an average sized horse with stout conformation that is in good condition is much better suited to a heavy rider than a larger horse that is out of shape or has weak conformation.

    From what I can see, your guy is built very well. Compact and sturdy with good legs under him. I see no reason at all why you couldn't enjoy him and ride as long as you choose at your current weight.

    Heck, if a person had to follow a 10% guideline, I wouldn't be able to ride half the horses I do LOL. At 10%, I'd have to have a horse that weighed 1750 to adequately carry me and my tack.

    The only advice I'll give is just to watch him and if he starts to act like he's struggling a little, then stop and give him a rest.
         
        07-22-2013, 04:18 PM
      #13
    Yearling
    Im going to compare two mares that we have. One is a 15.3hh approx 1200lb ssh. Fairly stout girl. At 5 yo and in what I consider very good condition. When I was at my heaviest 225lbs plus my 45 lb saddle she acted like she struggled going up and down steep hills with me. Kind of irritated me because one of the reasons I wanted her was because she was gaited and going to be stouter. Then the second mare is 14.1hh approx 900 lb very refinded twh. At my heaviest I maybe rode her twice because I felt sooo bad for her having to carry me. However, she moved with ease no matter where we went and she was not in good shape. She is also very toed out in the front.

    Its really hard to say whether someone is too much for a horse or not without seeing them ride and being able to feel how the horse is moving.
         
        07-22-2013, 05:24 PM
      #14
    Foal
    I don't think weight is the main factor - saddle fit is. In most english saddles, you should be able to fit a palm behind your butt on the saddle. This doesn't go for western saddles, because the seat in these are different, but generally for all saddles, if you'r bum goes over the cantle, if you can just barely squeeze your butt into the saddle, or if your butt only fits into a saddle that is too long for your horses back - then you're too big, no discussions. If you're bodyweight gets too far back in the saddle, you're putting the wrong pressure on the horses back.
    Sounds simple, yet many ignore it(or just never heard/thought about it).
    Rider weight and the condition, age and build of the horse, still matters of course. But I think saddle fit for the rider, is the best guideline :)

    So if it fits, you sits! ;) I think it's great that you care and think about it though, I think we all should.
         
        07-22-2013, 05:25 PM
      #15
    Trained
    Here are some threads that might help you think about the way ahead:

    Articles on riders weight effecting a horses soundness?

    Heavier Riders' Guide

    I'm about 175. With my tack, probably around 210+. Mia is around 900, so I've spent the last 5+ years riding her at about 23-24% of her weight.

    She is doing fine. As best I can tell by watching her, she enjoys our rides. Corrals are boring. Stretching her legs is fun. If that means carrying me along...well, so be it.

    Trooper weighs 830. That puts me over 25%. If he minds, he hides it well. Cowboy might be 700 lbs (13 hands). 30%. He dislikes ANYONE riding him in an arena, but acts happy and relaxed on trails. If I'm on him on the trail, though, I can feel him struggling with my weight at times. Of course, he gets ridden about 6 times a year and eats too much, so he is our fat little out of shape pony. But yeah, by 30% or more, one might want to think carefully. Limit the rides, or do not ride every day in a row, use a saddle that distributes the weight over a larger area, watch your speed, allow more room in a turn, etc.

    I read the 10% article. It was done by idiots.
         
        07-23-2013, 12:00 AM
      #16
    Showing
    I must have read the wrong info on battle horses. The heavily armored knight did ride the big war horse but only in battle. Other than that he wore little armor and rode a palfry which was quite a comfortable ride. The apprentice lead the war horse.
    Clava likes this.
         
        07-23-2013, 12:21 AM
      #17
    Weanling
    Thanks to all of you. I've always acknowledged that you can't make any decisions based solely on numbers, and not because I was trying to validate (I was leasing a 15hh, 1300-pound draft cross in excellent health with solid everything) but because of the reasons you all outlined (that health and conformation are what matter if you're talking within reason). Your examples and explanations solidified that for me, Joe and toosexy, et al.

    xdressage, thanks for the saddle info. I'm riding for now in an all-purpose English saddle that seems to fit well based on my seat and his sweat marks, but I'm buying a Western saddle soon that will improve the weight distribution.
         
        07-23-2013, 12:44 AM
      #18
    Yearling
    The Japanese have recently done a study that is far better than any others I have seen, that takes into account the conformation of the horse and the type of rider. It still needs more work and, when that comes out with a final result, it'll probably be one I listen to.

    I currently lease a 20+ year old 15.3HH QH who leaves a little to be desired conformation wise as he has a long back and is a little cow-hocked. 10% of his weight would mean that even my far skinnier beginner friend couldn't ride him! I'm a little over 20% of his weight, without tack. He carries me the same as he does a lighter person. He's never been sore in the back since I bought him a riser pad to get the saddle up off his ridiculous withers.

    Your boy looks more solid than mine, so I doubt he'd have any problems. However it is good to be mindful that you might be too big - it helps remind myself to ride light, and my seat has improved so much since I've been so aware of the fact that, at his age, my weight could be extra detrimental to his health.
         
        07-23-2013, 01:01 AM
      #19
    Weanling
    Good advice, Tracer. I always post at the trot and don't do gaming or anything extreme. I'll be sure to pay attention to how I ride, though.
         
        07-23-2013, 10:43 AM
      #20
    Trained
    Slightly off-topic, but Wiki has a good review of medieval war horses & their size:


    DimSum likes this.
         

    Thread Tools

    Similar Threads
    Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
    Little rider, big horse and BIG jumps! Kawairashii Ichigo Horse Videos 14 02-15-2012 04:59 AM
    Is this possible? Very timid rider owning a horse long term? Riding critique samc230 Horse Riding Critique 44 11-18-2011 10:39 PM
    From big strides to short choppy ones RedTree Horse Riding 21 07-07-2010 06:42 AM
    Big mohawk, medium mohawk, short mohawk, or keep it shaved? CloudsMystique Horse Grooming 26 03-27-2010 06:42 PM
    short term boarding - grumble/rant HayburnerHeights Horse Talk 12 03-27-2010 10:04 AM



    All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:15 AM.


    Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
    Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
    Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0