Natural Disaster By Aaron Ralston
This was written by Aaron Ralston
I predict most "Natural" horse people are fast approaching a "Natural Disaster"! I support the original methods made known by the Dorrance brothers, however, through the mass marketing networks, most new horse participants view "Natural" as a "Mythical" bond free of struggle and hardship. It feels good to say "I practice Natural Horsemanship". It makes you feel safe, noble and kind, but, nature isn't always safe, noble and kind.
"There is nothing Natural about horsemanship". From the first moment I heard the term "Natural Horsemanship" I have struggled to accept the term. We all interpret and filter the world to suit our ideals, therefore, I am not here to argue for one persons perception. Ultimately, I just want to think out loud to create the opportunity for myself to test the many ideas my mind creates.
I have heard it argued that the term Natural should be traced back to its root, Nature. Working with the nature of a horse is much easier for me to accept as a definition. Understanding the Nature of a horse is seeing the world from the horses perspective. Which is opposite of our primary attempt to personify our interactions with our horses. So, wouldn't Natural be the polar opposite of our Nature and therefore be considered artificial?
Again, I don't want to argue terminology as much as I want to spark a thought in a mind. As I was contemplating this idea one day, I thought about nature. Almost immediately I thought of harmony of energy, our internal empathy for safety, kindness and love, but then I thought about other sides of Nature. What about the cheetah killing the baby water buffalo? Or, What about Natural disasters? Nature can be cruel! Tornadoes, hurricanes, floods, fires, tsunami's....! In nature, we do not experience 365 days of perfect weather. Working with our horses is very similar to different weather climates, some days are sunny and others are a storm! Perhaps the hardest thing to accept about a cloudy day is the disappointment from our expectation of sunshine. But in Nature a horse lives through the struggles of the storms and learns to appreciate the sunshine. With out exposure to the storms we create a Natural horsemanship disaster. This protection from natures hardship disables a horses ability to exist in Natures Natural existence.
I am very fortunate to live in Colorado. We experience more sunny days than most climates and I believe it creates a strong positive mind. Other parts of the world have daily fog or frequent rain. I have read that these areas have a higher report of depression and negative thought. The natural climate we choose to live in or attempt to create has a direct effect on our mental outlook.
Now I have to ask the question, why create a storm for our horse? The best answer that comes to mind is a thought from author Dan Milman,"If your never sad, how do you know your happy?" The next answer I think of is from the mindset of stewardship. I owe it to my horse to teach them how to survive in a storm. If a Zoo animal is raised in a Zoo it will never be allowed to enter a natural environment. It is almost guaranteed to die when released into the wild.
Natural disasters have the greatest devastation when they occur in an area that is not prepared properly. Perhaps the results of Hurricane Katrina or the earthquakes of the feeble structured buildings of Iran can provide the importance of building a stronger resistance for the unexpected.
When exposing your horse to an artificial storm, be sure to use external stimulants to create challenges. It is very important for your horse not to associate you with the cause. Instead, you should be the answer they look for when the storm hits.
We don't have enough space here to go through my entire progression of preparing a horse for the storm, but in a very simple explanation I say, "If they take their feet away from you, take their feet away from them". If you contradict their self imposed movements consistently, then you will develop a horse that checks in with you instead of checking out.
Having control of a horses actions gives you control of their mind, therefore, entering a storm will give you and your horse confidence. Living through the storm will develop you and your horse in a way we can not duplicate through avoidance.
Don't let an unexpected storm turn into a natural disaster and be sure to enjoy the warm sunny days, but remember, a few storms make the sunny days feel even better!
I like this part in particular. This is really well put and is what my teacher talks a lot about. Thank you for sharing!
Thank you for sharing! I love watching Aaron's show on RFD-TV. I believe in taking methods from everyone and not just sticking to one, but I find Aaron has always made a lot of sense to me.
I read and reread the article and couldn't tell if he was advocating NH or disparaging it. He used a lot of words to be very ambiguous.
I am reminded of a line from act V scene V of Macbeth:
"...full of sound and fury, signifying nothing."
I didn't care for the article, which seems to meander without a solid point. While I disagree with "Black Stallion training", I think it misses the point in connecting BST with natural horsemanship.
As I understand it, natural horsemanship is just communicating with the horse in a way a horse can understand. That can include punishment, since horses punish each other - but horses don't like a bully horse, and neither will they give best effort to a bully person, unless in fear of their lives.
This statement conflicts with what I've been told: "Having control of a horses actions gives you control of their mind". I was taught, and believe, we do NOT control the horse's actions. We can only make it easier or more productive if the horse chooses to do what we want, and less pleasant or productive to do something else. From her back, I cannot make Mia put a hoof anywhere. However, I can make putting her feet where I want more pleasant than putting them somewhere else. And in her case, 'making it more pleasant' can include letting her see how doing it does something useful - she hates doing stuff 'just because'. She'll tolerate that for a while, but then become rebellious. And when she is rebellious, it decreases the chance that her will will fall in line with mine.
So if I try to teach her to canter endlessly in circles, I'll end up with a fight. If I ask her to canter to keep up with another horse...THAT she understands. And because she understands, she then learns to respond to my cues in a way she doesn't by just doing circles.
That is an example of getting inside her mind, appreciating her 'horseness' and will, and using it to achieve MY goals. And since horses are not all robots, how you approach each horse should vary based on the horse's personality.
I've had three kids, each wildly different. I don't take the same approach to them, or I'll get different results. To me, natural horsemanship applies that principle to horses, and strives to figure out both what most all horses share, and how they differ, and how to use that to get them to do what we want.
Just random thoughts. I haven't read a lot of 'natural horsemanship', so maybe I'm missing the big picture...
|All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:50 PM.|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.