The Horse Forum

The Horse Forum (
-   Horse Protection (/horse-protection/)
-   -   Cruelty trial at 3 yrs and counting. Ridiculous. (

franknbeans 03-08-2013 09:05 AM

Cruelty trial at 3 yrs and counting. Ridiculous.
Some of you may be aware of this case-it has been pretty high profile in Western NY. This is one more example of someone who may well get away with horrible cruelty, and never see jail time, much less reimburse the local SPCA for care of these 74 horses. Probably primarily because of her $$. Sickening. One delay after another.

Article in Buffalo News:

Horse saga has trudged far too long

It is way past time to put the whip to this thing.

The speed of horses is tracked on a racing form. Measuring the speed with which the notorious Beth Hoskins horse case has progressed requires multiple calendars. Glaciers move with more haste.

The animal-cruelty case against Hoskins involves her alleged mistreatment of 74 Morgan horses. Yet the criminal and civil cases have proceeded at the slow-motion pace of a grizzled plow-puller headed for the glue factory.

March 18 marks the third anniversary of the SPCA raid on the Curtis Screw heiress’ Aurora horse farm. SPCA officials say that some of the horses were starving and thigh-deep in manure. Fifty-one cats were found in a urine-soaked 10-by-12-foot shed.

What looked like a simple, sad case of animal hoarding has turned into a marathon legal absurdity. I know that the wheels of justice turn slowly, but it is time that an overly indulgent judge knocked the rust off of the gears.

The Nuremberg Trials didn’t take this long. This is a perfect storm involving a deep-pocketed defendant in apparent denial, an overly accommodating judge in Douglas Marky and the slow churn of a town court. Prosecutors put a reasonable misdemeanor plea deal on the table two years ago.

“It would be inappropriate, if not foolish, for me to comment on the speed with which the court has proceeded,” said Erie County District Attorney Frank A. Sedita III, his voice rising, “particularly when we have an ongoing trial.”

The only one popping corks as the third anniversary nears is Thomas Eoannou, the latest in a line of defense attorneys. He usually takes on bigger fish than animal-cruelty cases, but presumably does not mind having a persistent, check-writing client on the hook. Hoskins is the daughter of the founder of Curtis Screw Co., which reportedly does $68 million in annual business. It may be awhile before the account for attorneys dries up.

The most recent of numerous postponements – virtually all of them requested by Hoskins (and routinely granted by Marky) – involved a 100-day break extended by the defendant’s health issues. The illness abated just as her doctors were instructed to make an explanatory court appearance. Whether Hoskins’ sudden return to health is attributable to a miracle cure or to medical science, the nonjury trial mercifully resumed this week.

The prosecution still has a couple of witnesses to call, after which the defense makes its case. If Vegas were placing odds, my guess is the over/under on a resolution would be 4 years. I’ll take the “over.”

It would all be absurdly amusing, if it were not so costly – in time and money – to the nonprofit SPCA Serving Erie County. Barbara Carr, the SPCA’s executive director, told me the agency may be out the hundreds of thousands of dollars it spent caring for Hoskins’ animals in the months after they were seized. She said Hoskins owes tens of thousands of dollars for subsequent care.

There is no dollar figure put on the time that SPCA officials set aside for postponed court dates.

“ ‘Inconvenience’ is too mild of a word,” Carr said. “In my opinion, it’s an abuse of the system.”

An abuse of the system? No animal with four legs and a mane would say neigh.

waresbear 03-08-2013 09:13 AM

384 Attachment(s)
Instead of spending all that coin on defense attorneys, why didn't the accused spend it on caring for their starving animals??? Unreal, all of it!
Posted via Mobile Device

franknbeans 03-08-2013 09:22 AM

Exactly. A friend of mine is charged with managing the care of all of these horses. Some are even at her house. I also think if she is found guilty she should have to pay the back charges for caring for them. I would hope the SPCA (which is a non-profit) would sue for that at the very least. But our taxpayer $$ is going toward this ridiculous charade.

waresbear 03-08-2013 09:31 AM

384 Attachment(s)
If I was the ruler of such things, I would make her do restitution work, cleaning all stalls, paddocks & pastures, by HAND!
Posted via Mobile Device

WSArabians 03-08-2013 10:26 AM

We really need to get out **** together when it comes to convicting and handing out sentences for these type of people.

Elizabeth Bowers 03-15-2013 09:55 AM

just wow, how ridiculous!!! And i agree it's an abuse of the system!!! this is bulls#!&

Joe4d 03-15-2013 10:49 AM

ny has no system. Every wide spot in the road has its own completely independent government, complete with its own courts, highway depts, schools you name it. Sorta why governemtn is the states largest employer and they have nearly the highest local taxes in the country.

franknbeans 07-09-2013 08:57 AM

Update!! Guilty! Yay!!
Hoskins guilty of 52 counts of animal cruelty - City & Region - The Buffalo News

Finally. Let's hope she does not get to appeal and does some jail time.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:06 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
vBulletin Security provided by vBSecurity v2.2.2 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome